I live in DC. I was born here. I am a huge fan of all sports. I love the Wizards and the Redskins; I’ve grown to like the Nats despite still having strong feelings about the Orioles and I’ve even been to some Capitals games. I’ve been to over a dozen G-Town basketball games this past year, went to the BB&T Classic and every NCAA tourney game hosted here. I’ve even been to DC United games and once was almost convinced into going to a Mystics game, though I came to my senses barely in time. In short, I’m a huge sports fan in general and specifically a huge Washington sports fan.
Hell, I even write a 1,000+ word sports column online with a daily readership of almost a dozen people, so clearly I like sports. That’s why it pisses me off when people like Amy Sullivan; someone I normally love, writes in the Washington Monthly that DC has terrible sports fans. Please. I figure the best way to respond to Ms. Sullivan’s piece is to go team by team (the major ones people, i.e. Redskins, Wizards and Nats) and show that Ms. Sullivan has no clue what she’s talking about. So here we go.
Wizards Fans
The main thrust of Ms. Sullivan’s piece is an attack at Wizards fans or really the lack of Wizards fans. She talks about going to Wizards games and seeing lots of fans rooting for the opposing team and a general lack of interest in the team. Ms. Sullivan also calls the Wizards “a perennial playoff contenderâ€. Ok hold on for a minute here. Yes the Wizards have made the playoffs two years in a row but they aren’t the Spurs, OK? Two years ago they beat the Bulls in the first round before getting swept by the Heat and this year they got dropped by the Cavs in the first round.
Its not like fans haven’t been embracing a championship squad. Ms. Sullivan compares Wizards games now to what they were like during her time in Detroit during the late 80’s. Well yeah the intensity levels were different, the Pistons one two championships and were one of the best teams in basketball! They’ve made the playoffs two years in a row after years of mediocre or worse. They’ve been #5 seeds in the East two years in a row. So come on now, “perennial playoff contender� I think the phrase “comparing apples and oranges†is well applied to Ms. Sullivan’s comparison between the fans of the 80’s Pistons and the current Wizards fans.
Furthermore I was at every home Wizards game both this year and last and each game the place was packed and rocking with Wizards fan. I didn’t see a single Cavs jersey this year and the only Cavs fan I saw was Usher. She must be talking about regular season games when she’s talking about and even then the figures don’t really support her story. Washington finished 16th in the NBA in attendance; right in the middle but ahead of such teams as Boston, Philly and Indiana; all teams with much better histories then ours. Fine some people don’t show up to Wizards games and some maybe root for the opponents but we aren’t Atlanta or Orlando or LA Ms. Sullivan.
Nationals Fans
As I said Ms. Sullivan focuses most of her argument on the Wizards and their fans but she also talks about how in other cities immigrants support their adopted teams:
“But other cities absorb large numbers of outsiders and still manage to generate pride and unity among their residents. Part of becoming a New Yorker or Chicagoan is adapting to the local culture, adopting the Yankees or Cubs (or Mets or White Sox).â€
Now lets apply this logic to the Nats. We are currently half way through the Nats second season. They’ve had an owner for like an hour and he isn’t even in control of the team yet. They play in RFK for god’s sake, the worst stadium in sports. And yet still the Nats drew over 30,000 last year and despite attendance slippages this year are right in the middle of the pack in terms of MLB attendance.
How about this, for the last 30 years Washingtonians have had to go to Baltimore for baseball. Throughout her piece Ms. Sullivan talks about baseball allegiances. Forget immigrants assimilating and becoming Nats fans; native Washingtonians are still adjusting to rooting for the Nats and not the O’s. Many of them (myself included) haven’t made the switch yet. The cities Ms. Sullivan mentions have decades of baseball tradition and, perhaps more importantly in the case of the Yankees, winning tradition. How can anyone expect the Nats to have the same level fans as the Yankees or Cards after a year and a half? You can’t Ms. Sullivan, you can’t.
Redskins Fans
I’ve saved the best for last with Redskins fans. I’ll try to be very clear here: There are no better football fans in America then Redskins fans. Period, end of story. FedEx field is the biggest NFL stadium at over 90,000 seats and its sold out every game. The season ticket waiting list is well over 100,000 names long and takes years to get to the top. This town is never more alive then when the Skins are winning; Ms. Sullivan were you not here during the Skins playoff run? This is a football town; Joe Gibbs is a God here. At the Wizards games I’ve gone to, whenever they show a Skin sitting courtside (Clinton Portis, Brandon Lloyd, etc) the fans always, always broke out into a standing ovation. Of course these are the same fans at Wizards games that Ms. Sullivan thinks don’t care about their local teams. Anyway Redskins fans alone blow up Ms. Sullivan’s point.
It is impossible, or at least I thought it was, to live in Washington and not understand the intensity of the feelings the Redskins provoke. Hell, my mom, who couldn’t identify Coach Gibbs if he walked up to her holding a sign that said “I’m Joe Gibbs†asked me before the Seattle playoff game if I thought we had a chance to win. Say what you will about other fans Ms. Sullivan (even though I still think you are wrong) but you can not possibily question the loyalties of Skins fans. You just can’t.
So now that I’ve defended the specific honor of Nats, Wizards and Redskins fans lets look at some of the broader parts of Ms. Sullivan’s argument. Ms. Sullivan makes the point that Washington is largely made up of people who have moved here for work. This is very true but Ms. Sullivan goes the wrong way with this. I lived in Orlando for four years while at college. I watched Magic games frequently and hoped they’d win. At no point did I ever stop being a Wizards fan and every time the two teams played I rooted like hell for the Wizards. As any diehard sports fan knows, just because you move somewhere doesn’t mean you betray your team. If I moved to NY and lived there for forty years I’d still never, ever, become a Yankee fan. So when Ms. Sullivan writes
“When I talked to friends—most of them, like me, transplants from other cities—about the Wizards, the typical reaction was “Oh yeah, they’re in the playoffs, aren’t they?†They, not we.â€
it makes perfect sense. These people she’s talking to, as she admits, are not Washington natives who should root for the Wizards. They are transplants who, if they are performing their fan duties properly, are rooting for their home teams. So yeah its “they†and not “we†because that’s how its supposed to be. Its not Washingtonians fault that lobbyists buy up seats and don’t go to games. It’s a fact of life in DC that many of the good seats at games are bought by people who aren’t from here; they are bought by people associated with politics in some manner who have all come to DC to work. They still maintain their ties to their home teams; its not our fault they haven’t switched over.
So there you go. I do believe my response is longer then Ms. Sullivan’s original piece but drastic times call for drastic measures. Also she insulted my honor as a sports fan and of course I couldn’t let that stand. Maybe Ms. Sullivan will read this and see the error of her ways. How about this, I hereby invite her to attend any Washington sporting event with me (Redskins, Nats, Wizards, etc) and I’ll show her where the real fans are. I’ll even provide the tickets. Ball is in your court Ms. Sullivan. I think you are well intentioned and obviously a fan, you’ve just been hanging around the wrong people.
Let me also be very clear that I love Ms. Sullivan’s previous work and everyone should read her piece from I think last month on her boyfriend’s fantasy baseball obsession, this is just about defending my people. Oh, and here’s the last arrow in my quiver: If Washingtonians are such bad fans Ms. Sullivan, then why do the Mystics have all of those “attendance champions†banners up in the Verizon Center?
Simmons has a huge man crush
OK Jonathan Papelbon, the Red Sox closer, has been pretty sick this year, I think even Yankees fans can agree on that. But Simmons, in his latest ESPN the Magazine piece, goes a little overboard in his praise of the guy. Take, for instance, this statement: “He’s the best player on the team. There’s no question.” Um, no Bill, he’s really not. There’s a certain DH on the Red Sox, goes by Big Papi; he’s the best player on your team. He’s currently on pace for 49 HRs and 148 RBIs. He hit a jack last night. Lets not take David Ortiz for granted Bill. As for the rest of your arguement, that Papelbon should remain the closer and not be a starter, I’m not too sure about that either. Any team that has to pickup Jason Johnson from the Indians and Kyle Snider from the Royals to start games for them needs rotation help. If, as you say Bill, Papelbon can win 20 games then he needs to be stuck in there every 5 games. Come on Bill, don’t let love blind you to whats best for your team. Trust me, I’ve been there. I thought the Wizards should have been starting Andray Blache instead of Jared Jefferies all year.
World Cup Fix
As you are reading this the US is taking on Ghana in a must win. To advance the US needs to beat Ghana and have Italy beat the Czech Republic. The big question is will we see the US from the Italy game or the one from the Czech game. Lets hope for the former and not the latter. In other news England has lost striker Michael Owen to a torn ACL. Bummer for him and for the English. Tomorrow will be an interesting day: if the US loses soccer coverage will drop significantly; if they win it could get more intense. When you finish reading this go to a TV and support the squad. Be a man Landon, be a man.
What good timing
SI.com’s Tom Verducci writes a love letter to the Mets’ Jose Reyes and Reyes promptly goes out and hits for the cycle. Verducci’s point is that despite Reyes’ low OBP he’s still one of the best leadoff hitters in the game and to be quite honest he makes a pretty solid case. You can’t teach speed as they say and Reyes has speed to burn. I’d love to see Reyes, Carl Crawford and Corey Patterson in a race. It would be a photo finish but my money’s on Patterson.
Odds and Ends
Can you feel it? The NFL is coming. Can’t wait. ESPN.com put out its first Power Rankings of the season. Seattle, the Steelers, the Colts, the Broncos and the Panthers make up the top 5. The 49ers are dead last. Preseason is just around the corner folks.
New Royals GM Daytom Moore makes his first move, trading prospect JP Howell to Tampa for CF Joey Gathright. Seems like a smart move to me, I’ve always liked Gathright. The guy’s as fast as anyone, he just needs to prove he can hit consistently. The Royals have nothing to lose by sticking him in CF and letting him leadoff. Royals Review says its a marginal trade but that Howell has the higher upside. Oh well.
Um, Michael Strahan’s soon to be ex-wife says the defensive end has an “alternative lifestyle”. Who knew? Not that there is anything wrong with that. (via Deadspin)
Roger Clemens finally takes the mound Thursday against the Twins. I say he’ll strike out 8 in 6 innings.
Kerry Woods could be done for the year. You know when the Cubs finally trade Woods to someone for 10 cents on the dollar that Woods is going to win 20 games and a Cy Young for his new team. Ah to be a Cubs fan.
Correction
Yesterday we incorrectly wrote that Kobe Bryant had won a NBA Finals MVP award. Shaq actually won all 3 Finals MVPs from when the Lakers won their championships. Thanks to loyal reader the Italian Stallion for the correction and we regret the error.